Ridiculous headline: “Chargers and Cowboys are most deserving of a Super Bowl win.” Problem is that this is based on a flawed premise



Is "South America's Team" really deserving of a Super Bowl?
Logo: Pinterest
… the Vikings and Bills are more deserving than the nefarious 'boys

The Cowboys one of two teams that are “most deserving” of winning the next Super Bowl? I can agree that the Chargers are deserving, since they have never won a Lombardi Trophy.

First, the Cowboys have the most money, the most expensive venue, and the most financial resources of any team in the NFL. The fact that they have not won a Super Bowl in a quarter-century is their fault, and it does not mean that they deserve to win one.

Eleven other teams besides the Chargers have never won a Super Bowl, and some of them deserve one more than South America's Team.

So, how did this expert on “analytics” arrive at this conclusion?

Who is Bill James?

According to the author of the article, his headline is based upon the same formula that Bill James uses for baseball,

It’s easy to sit back and look at which teams are the contenders from year to year, yet the debate of which franchise is most deserving to win a championship is a little more intriguing, especially for the dozen teams which have never hoisted the Lombardi trophy. An by adapting some baseball metrics, we can actually measure this deservedness.

Bill James, widely considered the godfather of baseball analytics, presented one method to determine which baseball team was most deserving to win a World Series. He postulated “you deserve to win if you consistently put out a competitive team, which has a chance to win” and went about constructing a simple point system to rank franchises based on merit. It’s so simple, we can easily apply it to the NFL.

Neil Greenberg, “Chargers and Cowboys are most deserving of 
a Super Bowl win,” Washington Post, April 29, 2020

I have never heard of James, but his basic premise of “you deserve to win if you consistently put out a competitive team, which has a chance to win” obviously omitting some major teams that certainly deserve to win.

The whole idea of putting out a competitive team that has a chance to win means that those teams that do not put out a competitive team were not included in this.

Personally, I would like to see two teams that have come close to winning Super Bowls actually doing so: The Vikings and Bills.

The results


Here are those results, for what they are worth:

List of most deserving teams "according to analytics"

1. Chargers
2. Cowboys
3. Falcons
4. Panthers
5. Colts

Most deserving among teams that have never won the Super Bowl

1. Los Angeles Chargers, 52 points
2. Atlanta Falcons, 48 points
3. Carolina Panthers, 47 points
4. Minnesota Vikings, 42 points
5. Cincinnati Bengals, 40 points
T-6. Tennessee Titans, 39 points
T-6. Houston Texans, 39 points
8. Arizona Cardinals, 33 points
9. Jacksonville Jaguars, 31 points
10. Detroit Lions, 28 points
11. Buffalo Bills, 25 points
12. Cleveland Browns, 19 points



Neil Greenberg, Washington Post, April 29, 2020

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Remembering the toughest loss I ever experienced in approximately a quarter-century of coaching football. George Pasierb was a great coaching adversary.

Image
R.I.P. George Pasierb, 1946-2020 Shade-Central City High School football coach Photo: Tribune-Democrat No high school football fan could ask for anything better than this. On a beautiful sunny, warm afternoon on Saturday, October 30, 1982, in Nanty Glory, Pa., the battle featured a clash of two undefeated titans of the Appalachian Conference.  One was the preseason unanimous favorite to win the title, the other a veritable surprise that season, one that had built an 8-0 record entering that game.  This battle lived up to the pre-game hype, ending in a one-point decision that was not certain until the final play of the game.  I thought of this because the coach of the powerful Shade-Central City High School Panthers, George Pasierb, passed away earlier this week. He coached the Panthers for 20 years, but his best team was arguably that 1982 team that battled the Blacklick Valley Vikings on that Saturday afternoon before more than 3,000 ebullient fans.  And, the one-po...
Read more

Why did Tennessee-Chattanooga hire trainer Tim Bream despite his role in the alcohol-induced death of Tim Piazza at a Penn State frat?

Image
… was a live-in advisor at the fraternity On paper, Tim Bream has an impressive resume. Actually, very impressive — up to a point. That seems to be when Bream’s life appears to careen out of control. Bream, who resigned as Penn State trainer in Feb.,  was a graduate of Penn State with a bachelor’s degree in physical education, specializing in athletic training. He then attended West Virginia as a grad assistant trainer, where he received a master’s degree in Physical Education with an emphasis on Sports Science. All of this information is from his bio on the Penn State athletic site. He then worked his way up the ladder impressively, working at Syracuse, Vanderbilt, and finally at the University of Richmond, where he was the Director of Sports Medicine and Head Athletic Trainer. Then he received his big break, being name as Assistant Athletic Trainer for the Chicago Bears in 1993, and four years later, Head Athletic Trainer. He was with the Bears for 19 years when inexplicably,...
Read more

Why did Mike Tomlin start hiring black coaches after 15 years?

Image
Brian Flores … hiring Flores probably rankled Goodell To place this into context, understand that the only reason that the Steelers hired Mike Tomlin 15 years ago is because he was black.  Why? He had never even been a coordinator anywhere, never in the NFL. The only reason that he was interviewed was because of the “Rooney Rule.” That rule is one named after the late Dan Rooney who led the effort to force every NFL team to interview at least one black coach when it had head coaching openings.  The Steelers had focused their coaching search after Bill Cowher left on Ron Rivera, then a defensive coordinator for the Chicago Bears. Their interview with Tomlin was a peremptory one, something to satisfy the smell test.  After all, why interview a guy who was just a defensive coach? Coordinators are the people who are hired for the big gig.  Tomlin, though, is a great talker, and he wooed Dan Rooney so much that he was hired for the position.  Which begs the q...
Read more